Protect Your Assets, Protect Your Life

Tolar Agency Inc. logo

Welcome to Tolar Agency

For more than four decades, Tolar Agency has been providing different types of insurance to clients in Fayetteville, NC, and the surrounding areas. From providing a simple liability policy for your 10-year-old vehicle to providing comprehensive business insurance with an umbrella policy, we can do it all!

Our principal agent, Sharon, and our other licensed insurance agents combine strong insurance backgrounds and product knowledge to help both current and future clients manage and plan for all types of risk.

Explore the different types of insurance available!

Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Miscellaneous Insurance

Insurance Providers We Represent

Tolar Agency works with everyone from homeowners and motorists to small businesses, ATV riders, and farmers.

Nationwide logo
Employers' logo
CNA logo
American Reliable Insurance Company logo
First Comp logo
Hagerty logo
Lloyd's logo
USLI logo
Atlantic Casualty logo
Chubb logo
The Hartford logo
Foremost Insurance Group logo
The Chartis Group logo
Progressive logo
American Modern logo

When you choose Tolar Agency, we will explore all of the insurance providers that we have to offer in order to give the best policy available, personalized for you.

Customer Reviews

“Great service at Tolar Agency, always!”

“Sharon Eaton is the best insurance broker around!”

Have we helped you with your insurance needs? We would love for you to review our agency.


Monday - Thursday
8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 8:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday: By Appointment
Sunday: Closed

Follow Us:


*Note: Messages sent using this form are NOT confidential. Avoid sending highly confidential information or private information through this system.